IFish Fishing Forum banner

"Ideal" barrel length for .17 HMR rifle?

28K views 8 replies 4 participants last post by  Ni!  
#1 Ā·
While most centerfire rifle cartridges benefit in velocity by longer barrels (usually ~50fps per additional inch), this is not necessarily the case with rimfire firearms.

A number of years back I read an article in the American Rifleman magazine, where the author had taken a .22LR rifle with a "20 something inch" barrel and chronographed various ammunition types through it.

He then proceded to shorten the barrel, 1 inch at a time, and chronograph the ammo over again.

What he came up with was that for his barrel, it reached its HIGHEST VELOCITY at a length of 18".

In other words, the powder was expended and bullet acceleration was peaked at 18" and beyond that, barrel friction started slowing the bullets back down.

So I was wondering if anyone here had done enough research on the subject to determine what length is "best" for a .17 HMR?

I have a friend who keeps telling me how great his .17 HMR rifles are.

Thinking about it, one of the thriftiest ways to go would be to simply get a .17 HMR barrel for my T-C Contender. I can order the barrel in any length between 16-1/4" to 26" long!

Since it would have a scope mounted, the ideal length would be where the peak velocity for this cartridge is reached.

Anybody out there have any ideas on this?
 
Discussion starter · #5 ·
On a serious note, have you ever been out to Varmint Al's web page? If not, look him up and read his tests of the 17HMR. I thought it was going to be the usual fare, but I ended up impressed and informed by his report. Well worth the time to read.

Skein
Thanks Skein,

I have been to Varmint Al's, but haven't looked at what he had to say about the .17 HMR.

It's only been recently that I've had my interest piqued on this. Having a two .22 Hornets (rifle, pistol), a .222 Sako HB, and a 40X in both .223 and .220 Swift, it's easy to overlook "recent developments" in the (mistaken?) attidude of "What For?"

But then, we know "What For"! It's a new cartridge and that means new/different guns to play with! :cheers:

That's What For! :grin:
 
Discussion starter · #6 ·
I checked with Hornady on this and they told me that the max velocity for the .17 HMR occurs in 22". The velocity will remain the same for another inch or two then friction will start slowing it down.

Shorter than this they say (in rifle lengths) will decrease the velocity by ~25fps/inch.
 
Discussion starter · #8 ·
Interestin results...

Did you notice that the 21" barrel shot faster than the 20" barrel (with the 19" barrel shooting the fastest!)?

It's interesting to note that one EXTRA-slow round in the 20" 5-shot string dropped the average velocity for the entire string's average.

With those lower velocities occuring in several of these strings and none in others, it seems like the results could be skewed a little. Did you notice that while the 22" barrel had the lowest velocity round in it, it also had the HIGHEST velocity round also.

Seeing this, I'm surprised they didn't try something like 20-shot strings in an effort to reduce the effects of anamolous data points.

It looks to me like you could get 4 out of 5 "faster" rounds in any barrel length between 19" and 22" and have gotten the highest velocity. In other words a "luck of the draw" situation.