IFish Fishing Forum banner

beads: hard or soft?

17K views 24 replies 18 participants last post by  scottsduckboat  
#1 ·
First year bobber fishing last year using beads with some success. Have had in the past, success swinging beads with my spey for Winter steel. Used plastic beads but soft beads logically makes some sense. Any experience or opinions on hard vs soft?
 
#2 ·
Been a hard bead fisherman for a couple of years until I was turned onto some soft beads fro BnR Tackle. I really like the color choices and their feel so I have been trying them out. They come with a tube that the bead slides onto and a red stopper that goes on your line. Neat concept but I was having trouble worth the bead sliding off the tube. So, a friend of told me about a solution he found that has worked out wonderfully for him.......................

Throw away the tube and the stopper and just use a large diameter dacron bobber stop and slide the bead onto that. Seems to grip it very well and have not had an issue since............

Haven't tried it myself yet but we'll see........

I really like the BnR beads so I'll have to figure something out to continue using them as their are a very fine product.
 
#4 ·
The argument with traditional bead fishing is for a neutrally buoyant presentation.
Hard beads sink and bounce, becoming one with the river. Achieved with long leaders, split shot and a hard bead.

I believe the soft bead concept was tried years ago with Jensen eggs, Goey Bobs etc.

I don't believe they yield the same results.
 
#5 ·
The argument with traditional bead fishing is for a neutrally buoyant presentation.
Hard beads sink and bounce, becoming one with the river. Achieved with long leaders, split shot and a hard bead.

I believe the soft bead concept was tried years ago with Jensen eggs, Goey Bobs etc.

I don't believe they yield the same results.
Jensen eggs were/still are very popular. No longer made, but Scott Amerman just sold a bunch of his secret stash for a decent profit, so somebody's gotta be having success with them!
 
#8 · (Edited)
Jensen eggs are popular for side drifting. Most of my bead work is with an indicator (little bobber) on a fly rod or under a small float on the spinning rod. Hard plastic or hevi beads are both very effective. I tend to use plastic ones when i roll the beads on bottom. Hevi when suspended, the can shatter when bounced through rocks, and are pretty snaggy.

Soft or hard, does not matter to me as far as if a fish will eat them. The way I fish them (IMO) results in a very high eat/hookup ratio. No time for a fish to chew it.
 
#16 ·
They all work very equally well.

I have two cases of jensen eggs, and they work very well which would explain why I bought a second case of them.

BnR (Brandons) eggs do work well. A big rubber red egg coupled with some white yarn is a J-Bob special. They can be drift fished, side drifted, or floated under a bobber.

Everything has a better way to be fished whether drifted or bobber. Hard beads should be fished under a bobber from my findings.

I always love a jenson egg, and a corkie doubled up on the drift rod or two jenson eggs.

Bobber stops or tooth picks to hold up the beads would be my suggestion. Certain buddies always use bobber stops so to not pin the bead, but I am not so certain this matters.
 
#19 ·
I like to pretie all my leaders for bobber-doggin and side drifting from my sled and this means pre-tied bead droppers.

Most of the soft plastics made now adays are corrosive and will melt plastic and foam... foam like the leader roll's i make my pretieds on... this means I either have to add the beads while on the water... or pre tie with hard beads.. so far I have used hard beads and found success... I have used soft beads but only walk/wade fishing.