IFish Fishing Forum banner

Evinrude E-TEC 225 HO 2010 any reviews or opinions please?

1 reading
22K views 21 replies 14 participants last post by  derrick454@  
#1 Ā· (Edited)
Hi looking at a 2010 Evinrude E-TEC 225 HO any reviews, opinions, or advice would be appreciated. I have always ran Mercury/ Hondas and no nothing good or bad about these motors. Anything I should look out for or check in particular. Or read.

Thank You Josh
 
#4 Ā·
I have a 2010 25 E-TEC.
I have over 800 hours mostly trolling.
I love it!



For you, you need a complete diagnostic history print-out.
You need all service records.
You need compression checks on all cylinders, info on the injectors, fuel pumps, water pump, everything.

A good service dealer is your best friend.

Do not buy it with out having it checked out by a trained E-TEC technician.

I can recommend Channel Marine Services, off 30, near Scapoose.

If it turns out to be in good shape, you will be thrilled with the performance and fuel economy.

Good Luck,

Lew
 
#6 Ā·
I ran this 2009 E-Tec 225 for 4 years before upgrading boats. I let the E-Tec go because the old boat would have been much less marketable without power.



http://
This picture is great!!...but it confuses me. Its a great action shot of you and your daughter, but what is everyone looking at, and taking photos of, on the other side of the boat?
 
#10 Ā·
When my 3 yr. service was done this year, the tech said it was programmed for TCW-3. I've been running the XD-100 with no problems. Tech said plugs were looking great so I'm not about to change oil or the setting.

When I run non-alcohol gas, mileage is pretty good. Not like the Honda I had but not complaining for sure. Can't say what the consumption actually is because lots of those hours on the water are consumed by the kicker. I can go five days at B-10 from Rice Island to actual B-10, up and down all over the place, on less than 30 gallons through the 150. I keep RPM's under 3800, MPH under 35.
 
#13 Ā·
Had a 2009 150hp on my 21ft sled. LOVED it! Mine was a pump, flew out of the hole, never had any problems. They can hook a computer up to it and tell you pretty much anything about it, how long it's been run at every RPM range etc. I can't remember exactly cost of that, but you're probably talking pennies compared to what you're about to spend on it. The only slightly negative is that not every place sells the oil, I'd just stock up when Cabelas did their 20% off lubricants/oils once or twice a yr.
 
#14 Ā·
I re-powered my 20 foot G-W about 7 years ago with a 200HP E-Tec to get the best power to weight ratio. So far quite happy with it; no longer a dog when trying to get up on plane. (Original purchaser somehow thought a 140 Evinrude would be enough on that heavy boat and I lived with that decision far too long before re-powering.)

Fuel consumption much more reasonable and it is quiet!
 
#19 Ā·
IMHO when most folks think about 2-strokes they recall that 1985 smokin' pukin' carbeurated gas hog that made them gag when running from the tiller. When 4-stokes came on the scene they were virtually smokeless, quiet and would idle down when trolling. As early adopted starting bragging about their sweet motors others took a good look at repower time and made the move. Newer 4-strokes are even sweeter with fuel injection and computer enhanced timing. They are truly fine motors.

As technology continued with 2-strokes, many of the complaints were addressed and both Evinrude and Mercury rolled out DFI motors that are powerful and quiet. E-Tec and Opti are both solid motors, but E-tecs were more heavily advertised and marketed. Their long warranty period beats Merc as well. Either is a fine alternative to the normal Yammie/Honda/Zuke 4-strokes. However, having lost market share to the 4-strokes, E-Tecs and Optis will likely remain niche motors. Folks that have been running a 4-stroke Yammie for the last ten years will probably repower with another one.
 
#17 Ā·
I'm guessing it mostly the convenience of not having to deal with the oil injection.

If we turn the question around and ask, why choose E-Tec over regular 4 strokes, we may get a variety of reasons? I'll answer based on owning both. My four stroke experience is based on Mercury/Yamaha 115 and Honda 150. I loved my Honda. The E-Tec has tremendous part throttle torque/power without going into the upper RPM range which makes it very economical. Because of this, a person can use a lower HP rated motor for general travel. I've never had my motor over 4,200 rpm and usually run it between 3,400 and 3,800. Water is rarely smooth enough to want to go any faster than 30 mph. I'm a wimp. I will say the prop that came with the motor really likes 4,200 (40 mph) and above. Don't know the weight savings between the different motors but a person could look it up fairly easy. The overall size of the various choices may also be a consideration?

I think HP rating of over 200 is a big waste on anything other than a large heavy, fiberglass, ocean boat. I wouldn't go more than 150 with the E-Tec on your basic open sled till the length exceeded 24 ft. I don't know how that relates to the weight of the boat/load? This opinion is based on my boat/motor.