There are no unbiased opinions and each camp will find "facts" to back their arguements. I believe hatcheries are like dams they will never go away. We need to keep making improvements and debates like this lead to new innovations. I personally like to have the opportunity to catch and keep Salmon and Steelhead and it seems to me that broodstock programs are less damaging than old methods in providing that opportunity. As of now I will support broodstock programs. Bottom line, let's keep talking, researching, and making improvements.