I'd have to say wild yellowtail.
However there aren't no hatchery yellow's to comapare with.
Seriously the last 3 years I've been fishing a bank spot on the Columbia where fishing & catching is phenominal (thank you WDFW for allowing us to buy a second steelhead card now).
The conditions are the same for all the fish and they are all just moving along the bank migrating upstream.
When it comes to the bigger fish, you rarely see a unmarked dud.
And those duds could possibly be unmarked hatchery fish.
Hatchery fish you catch quite a few duds.
Overall on the larger fish (8-12 #'s) unmarked fight better on average.
But when those small 4-5# upper river hatchery dinks come in, in late July, a lot of those puppies will tear you a new, uh, well they surprisingly kick (how do you say it without getting edited)
.
You do see a large number of unmarked dinks mixed in but I have to think those are Tribal fish or something other than wild steelies from the gravel and I haven't noticed any difference in fighing abilities.
They all go balisitic and normally do their Michael Jordan thing.
I fished the Yaquina Bay hatchery coho brat's the last year ODFW used coho before changing over to chinook stocks.
There was all the difference in the world between the wild and hatchery fish and often times an angler would call it a wild coho correctly before anyone was able to see it.
We see this sometimes with Cowlitz coho also and sometimes it's "fish on" and then abruptly, "in the boat" (hatchery fish).
By the way Brad, looking at your poll decriptions...what's a "wild typically fish"?