I have fished it probably 10-15 times in the past 3-4 years. I've fished it from the trout opener clear into about this time. There are fish in there, I won't deny that. I have caught fish just using worms off the bottom (mooching style rig with 2 hooks). But I have caught some bass using small Rapalas and grubs as well. A friend of mine caught a 2.5lb LMB the first time I fished it (about 4 years ago). He was using a small rainbow trout-colored rapala. That is the biggest fish I've ever seen caught out of there. The fish are finicky but they are in there. You can also fish a worm underneath a bobber. We always fished on the far right side of the lake, in the little cove near the walking bridge. I have also caught catfish, carp, perch, and bluegill using worms.
Hope it helps