Gottafish,
Cool!
Yes, there sure are a lot of Training Methods out there.
I've always figured the "trick" between Pro-trainers and casual amateurs (there ARE some highly
skilled Amateurs out there) is that the books, vids, magazine articles show you "what to do", and this often works well.
But, sometimes it doesn't!
And the difference is the experienced "Pros" usually know what to do next, whereas the amateurs may hit a brick wall.
One thing I might mention to you is that even though you may have become "burned out" on the Retriever Trials, you might consider running/training your pup in some of the Port-Van Pointing Dog Club's trials.
These NSTRA based picnic trials are ENTIRELY DIFFERENT from a Retriever Trial!
These are "Shoot to Retrieve" trials where dogs (seriously for Derby and Open dogs) are run head-to-head in two dog braces. They're effectively "mini-hunts" with numerious live birds (Quail) planted and each Handler/Gunner has an assigned judge. Dogs are then scored on their finds, retrieves, ground race, and obedience (as well as extra points for honoring another dog's find 1X ).
These are all the traits that you'll want your gun dog to exhibit, and by running/comparing your dog with others, you'll get good feedback about where your dog stands in comparison with other trained dogs.
These picnic trials are really fun to run in and the cost, $15/dog at last check, isn't prohibitive. They're great training aids as there are some very experienced trainer/handlers there to help with training problems, meet fellow bird dog enthusiasts and avid fellow bird hunters.
Where else are you going to be able to run your dog with/against other bird dogs on a minimum of 5 Quail for $15?
I used to be very active in this until they switched their club trial days to Sundays, which is a work day for me, and I had to drop out.
Here's a pic of a big, registered NSTRA Trial. Same rules, just longer braces, judges horse mounted and running against the "big boys".